The Disability
Insurance Trap (Read This Article Carefully)
One out
of every four Americans will miss at least 90 consecutive days of
work because of an injury or sickness between the ages of 35 and 65.
Disability insurance can help prevent such medical disasters from
becoming financial disasters.
However, disability insurance is usually obtained through deeply flawed
group policies offered by employers. Employees with such group coverage
often aren't adequately protected.
Here's what to watch out for and how to get the best coverage.
PROBLEMS WITH EMPLOYER PLANS
The employer-sponsored disability policies in which all or part of
the premiums are paid by the employer, generally claim to replace
60% or 70% of an employee's income when he/she is disabled beyond
the typical 90 or 180 day elimination (or waiting) period. However,
these promises are empty and deceptive. Insurers are allowed to reduce
the benefits they pay dollar for dollar for any benefits the disabled
employee receives from his state workers' compensation program ...
Social Security disability program... the state's disability program
... and even cash settlements received for pain and suffering if the
employee was injured in an accident that caused his disability.
Even worse: Any money these insurers pay out to group disability policy
holders is taxed. Beneficiaries end up with only a small fraction
of what they thought they were insured for.
Other drawbacks...
- An employer might eliminate its disability plan at any time.
- An employee may not be able to take this disability policy with
him if he quits or is fired.
If a claim is ultimately denied, an employee in the group plan must
appeal the denial in a timely manner, then sue in federal court to
recover only his past-due benefits, some interest and attorney fees
if the court allows. The horror of group disability litigation is
that there is no trial by jury, no recovery for emotional distress
and no opportunity to seek punitive damages under the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act (ERISA). The carrier is required to pay only what
it owed - this is like robbing a bank and returning the money years
later without any penalty or jail time.
ADVANTAGES OF INDIVIDUAL COVERAGE
It is best to purchase your own individual disability coverage through
an insurance agent, whether or not you are covered through your employer's
group plan. You will be given the maximum benefit you're owed, tax
free, even if you get other forms of compensation for your injury
... you, not your employer, have control over the coverage ... and
if necessary, you can take the insurer to court, get a trial by jury
and seek not only the benefits owed but also punitive damages if your
state allows.
The downside is cost. A 55-year-old man in good health might spend
$280 per month for a well-designed disability policy that replaces
60% of wages up to $4,000 a month after a 90 day waiting period. A
55-year-old woman might spend around $325
(women are more likely to become disabled, thus their coverage will
cost more). For a 45-year-old man, the cost might be $199 a month.
For a woman, it might be $281 a month.
Two ways to cut the cost of your coverage...
*Increase your waiting period from 90 to 180 days. This should reduce
premiums by about 20% compared with a 90-day wait, but this strategy
makes sense only if you can afford to live half a year without income.
With a six month waiting period, you begin to accrue payable benefits
in the seventh month and would get a check at the 225th-day (seven-and-a-half
month) mark.
(Author)